Stuyvesant's School Spirit Needs Support
What does it mean to have school spirit? We often see school spirit portrayed in the media through colorful pep rallies, school dances, and crowded bleachers. While Stuyvesant High School seems to have all the ingredients needed to mimic the classic American high school experience—our show-stopping football and cheer teams, our student caucuses, and our robust Alumni Association, to name a few—our school shows a palpable lack of school spirit. There is a defined disconnect between having these resources in place and having an enthusiastic, unified student body.
Stuyvesant’s poor school spirit can be traced to a myriad of issues. For one, different grades have an uneven number of grade-wide events. While seniors have Senior Sunrise, Senior Skip Day, Senior Sunset, and Senior Prom, underclassmen usually have far fewer opportunities to partake in grade-wide gatherings. Upperclassmen look forward to Junior and Senior Prom throughout the school year, but freshmen and sophomores have no equivalent for their grade. Stuyvesant also has no homecoming dance, which is a yearly tradition in other high schools around the country. If all students were able to attend at least one proper school dance a year, with a dress code, good food, music, and a dance floor, they would not only get the chance to bond with their classmates, but also have an exciting event to keep spirits high during the school year.
Even schoolwide commitments like our Stuyvesant Theater Community productions, SING!, and various sports tournaments that get students collaborating and mingling eagerly are often geared towards niche and centralized interests. This raises the question of how schoolwide events can be organized with everybody’s interests in mind, so that as many students as possible feel encouraged to participate.
Besides the lack of fun and inclusive events, Stuyvesant has a poorly established brand within the student body. Our school colors are unclear, and there is a lack of spirited decor in the building. The school mascot is Pegleg Pete, but there is no widely circulated depiction or costume of him. School merchandise is also expensive, with hoodies costing over $50. This makes it financially difficult for students to express school spirit, as most students can’t afford any official school swag.
During Halloween week, students dress up for Spirit Week with their friends, following themes such as “Dress as Your Type” and “Color Wars,” culminating in showing off their Halloween costumes to their classmates. While there were a number of entertaining inflatable costumes on display from students this year, the other four days of Spirit Week were not very successful. Few committed to Color War Day, when students were supposed to dress in specific colors according to their grade, and Dress as Your Type Day was even less spirited.
One major impediment to school spirit could be Stuyvesant’s course rigor, which leaves students little time for fun events. With tests, projects, and extracurriculars, students have little energy left to dress up and coordinate outfits with friends for Spirit Week, for example. This is only amplified by the productivity culture at Stuyvesant: anything unproductive or frivolous, even if it brings fun to the school day, can be seen as a waste of time.
Stuyvesant has earned a reputation for its intense environment and academically obsessed students. While that stereotype is often exaggerated, the sense of competition doesn’t exactly breed school spirit either. Gaining admission into Stuyvesant is more of a personal achievement than an entry into a school community. This fosters a collective sense of pride over individual success, but not necessarily a connection to other students. People can begin to feel like they’re on their own, without the strong bonds to their classmates that might encourage participation in student engagement festivities.
However, given how much pride Stuyvesant has in its academic excellence, it’s surprising how little school spirit there is. On a college-level, nationally ranked institutions such as Harvard and Yale tend to have much more enthusiastic school spirit. The annual Harvard-Yale football game, for example, sees students from both universities fully decked out in their school colors. Stuyvesant can learn from this by finding ways to increase student interest in attending sports games and cheering on their sports teams. With a more well-established mascot and greater use of school colors, school sport events could be a great way to foster school spirit.
School administrators could also encourage the faculty to dress up for Spirit Week. While some staff, like Assistant Principal Casey Pedrick, showed off exciting, thought-out costumes on Halloween, the majority of teachers did not dress up during the week at all. If Stuyvesant encouraged teachers to engage with Spirit Week and school traditions, more students would be inspired to show increased engagement as well.
However, improving school spirit requires real effort from students too, not just from the administration. Many students choose not to participate in initiatives like Spirit Week, either due to overwhelming responsibilities and stress, or just indifference. This issue is particularly noticeable with underclassmen, who may not feel like they’ve found their place in the school yet. The key, then, is figuring out how to create real motivation to show school spirit. Strong spirit requires a strong foundation, and a more intentional Big Sibs program or increased freshman outreach would encourage students to be excited and invested in school spirit right from the start of their high school journey.
As Stuyvesant students, it can be challenging to appreciate the more sentimental side of our school community. Being a Stuyvesant student doesn’t just mean studying for tests or getting good grades; so much of the high school experience is defined by meaningful relationships, shared memories, traditions, and pride. Participating in school spirit activities and taking an interest in the community, whether that be by showing support for the robotics team, dressing up for Spirit Week, or attending the homecoming football game, is what makes Stuyvesant worth being a part of. After all, all 3,261 of us are spending four years of our lives here. We might as well make it worthwhile and fun.
