Arts and Entertainment

YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING and the Art of Deception

You Can See Everything is a riveting new documentary following disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes as she attempts to rewrite public opinion of her.

The following contains spoilers.

Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s new A24 documentary You Can See Everything strives to give viewers a deep, never-before-seen look at the mind and motivations of disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes. To those who aren’t familiar with the debacle, Holmes dropped out of Stanford in 2004 to found Theranos, a blood testing startup that claimed to be able to run more than 200 tests on a single drop of blood in a desktop machine. It was later uncovered to be a multi-billion-dollar sham, with Holmes and her partner Ramesh (Sunny) Balwani at the center of the scandal. Their tests never worked, and worse, they knowingly faked test results to achieve certification, which led to patient health being put at serious risk. A Wall Street Journal investigation uncovered this with the help of whistleblowers, and Holmes became subject to much public attention, including the hit HBO show The Dropout. Now, Holmes has separated from Balwani, stepped away from the public eye, has become engaged to businessman Billy Evans, and has begun using the name Liz. She was sentenced to a 123-month prison sentence in 2022. You Can See Everything, primarily shot in 2023, follows a documentary crew as they watch Holmes and Evans in the days leading up to her prison surrender. 

The film opens with Holmes and Evans in their vacation home near Del Mar, California. Canadian comedian Nathan Fielder is notably present and inquisitive, while Holmes is completely unrecognizable: her signature low, monotone voice is gone, and her dominating personality is completely missing. She attempts it, but Fielder cuts through the act. “It took me a really long time to be okay with letting someone see me cry,” Holmes says, as she conjures a tear. Fielder replies deadpan, and his presence as a comedian is not lost.

Throughout the film, the viewer comes to learn more of Holmes’s deception, as well as Evans’s willingness to support her unconditionally. She claims early on that the Theranos machine could run any test—as if the machine were fully functional (a court found Holmes guilty; it is widely accepted that the machine did not work). When pressed on this claim, Holmes doubles down and resorts to stretching the definition of the word “can” to include future possibilities that have not yet been realized (and may never be realized). Later, when asked if she’d ever been untruthful in her life, she denies it. To this, Nathan Fielder emphatically replies, “Liz, what?”

The film itself is a work of art, and it blurs the lines between truth, doubt, and objective capture. It’s beautiful, especially with its composition and coloring. Oppenheim and cinematographer David Bolen are true masters of the craft. The film’s coloring has a delightful way of playing with the blacks, the blues, and the dreamy highlights. It’s almost surreal and warm, while at the same time, incredibly moody. Paired with Ari Balouzian’s score, the film keeps the audience glued to the edge of their seat. Most impressively, they shot most of the scenes with no external lighting—no studio rigs, flood panels, or softboxes. The picture on the screen is entirely the result of natural lighting. The sun often peeks through the windows, illuminating the subject’s face. This translates to an incredibly natural and intimate film that feels like home.

Plainly, Holmes and Evans wanted this film to cast doubt on Theranos’s public, proven record. Fielder did not fall for it. Throughout the film, we learn more about the project’s origins: it was the couple who approached A24 with the idea, and Evans even negotiated for himself to get compensation for this film (though this was changed after filming concluded). They attempt to paint Holmes as an unsuspecting victim who thinks different. The clever lies make the audience question whether perhaps Holmes herself is so deep in her deceit that she too has begun to believe it. As for her motivations, even more doubt has muddied the waters: is Evans a controlling presence over her life, the same way Balwani was in the Theranos days? Could Holmes be a victim? 

The crux of the film comes when the couple leaves the beach house and Holmes surrenders to the Federal Prison Camp in Bryan, Texas. Amanda Seyfried, who starred as Holmes in The Dropout, returns to reenact some off-camera scenes as Holmes. It’s uncanny, but hilarious. Through conversations with Evans alone, the audience learns the extent of his control over Holmes’s life. He manages her public appearance, her Twitter, and her Power of Attorney. He’s also an odd character, claiming he’s angry and seeking vengeance on Holmes’s detractors. He owns a gun, which he carries 24/7. He makes an AI version of Holmes their children can interact with while she’s incarcerated. He’s building a blood-testing startup that has been dubbed Theranos 2.0, with the help of letters from Holmes. The peak of the mania comes as he says, “Every action she takes for as long as she lives will be building monuments of love to me.” 

Holmes now sits in prison, eagerly seeking early release. Evans continues to control her Twitter/X feed, though some posts are now specifically marked with her initials. Theranos 2.0 remains a mystery, as does the truth about Elizabeth Holmes: is she a deceptive, pathological liar, or the victim of abusive, controlling partners? This documentary might let you see everything, but should you believe everything?