Opinions

We are not horses. We are humans.

Prediction markets risk narrowing our engagement with the world around us.

Recently, it’s seemed impossible to escape the constant presence of online betting platforms. Just last week, I was indulging in my nightly social media scroll when another Kalshi advertisement appeared, promising that a simple prediction could earn me big cash, fast. This growing phenomenon of prediction platforms extends beyond just my feed: Bank of America’s consumer account data showed that participation in online betting rose by 40 percent between January and July in 2026. Virtually overnight, betting seems to have become another component of existing online. 

Apps like Kalshi operate like prediction markets. They allow users to buy and sell contracts based on the outcomes of real-world events, with the opportunity to earn money based on the accuracy of their bets. One factor of their success is the wide range of topics the prediction questions cover, from sports to politics: Will Trump win the midterms? Will the United States enter another war? Will NYC ban horse-drawn carriages this year? The appeal is easy enough to understand. People already speculate about elections and argue over sports; prediction markets offer a chance to get paid for being right. But behind the appeal of winning easy cash lies a question worth examining further: What are we conditioning ourselves to care about when every new headline becomes just another opportunity for a payout? 

The problem is not just that these markets reduce complex realities to simple yes-or-no questions. It is that they reward us for answering one narrow question while leaving all the important surrounding ideas unexplored. An election becomes only about the winning candidate and an economic crisis is reduced to a price change. The underlying causes of election results and the people affected lose center stage as uncertainty becomes a form of currency. 

In the process, we are primed to ask whether something will happen, rather than why it is happening or how we can address it. This distinction might seem subtle, but it fundamentally changes the role we take on as participants of society: we become reduced to spectators waiting for an outcome to settle. 

Even in sports, where being a spectator is part of the appeal, financial stakes can change what we are watching for. A National Collegiate Athletic Association study found that 36 percent of Division I men’s basketball student-athletes who were surveyed reported social media abuse related to sports betting within the past year. Although this finding concerns sports betting in a broader sense, it exemplifies what can happen when spectators have money riding on someone else’s performance. A missed shot at a basketball game gets turned into a financial loss for which an athlete is blamed. The athlete playing begins to matter less than a missed payout.

This is not to suggest that everyone who trades on betting apps like Kalshi is indifferent to suffering, or that a numerical prediction system is inherently shallow. Probability is woven into the foundation of human existence, and prediction markets can help aggregate information that traditional polling forecasts might miss or inadequately cover. 

In all fairness, prediction markets can have value in the way that they encourage users to research more deeply into a broader range of topics they might have otherwise overlooked. Someone who has never followed policy might be more likely to read about the Senate race in Michigan if they’re interested in placing an accurate bet, which can result in an increase in civic engagement. Yet, the incentive to understand an event only insofar as that understanding yields a profit remains a moral issue. When we repeatedly approach events through winning or losing contracts, we risk letting that binary perspective replace a more nuanced worldview.

In this sense, prediction markets reflect a broader tendency in digital media to make complicated subjects more accessible through numbers. Social media already rewards immediate reactions; it pushes out catchy headlines and distorts reality. Market odds fit naturally into this environment by allowing viewers to follow a single figure and by offering them a clear position to take. The result is the illusion of understanding without actually knowing the substance of a topic.

This is especially troubling for a generation that tends to learn about major world events through the same outlets it uses for entertainment. Turning these events into financial opportunities adds another reason to scroll past their actual significance and invalidates the people who are impacted by the headlines. When the odds become the most visible measure of an event, they begin to stand in for the event itself. Young people aren’t incapable of nuanced thinking nor particularly vulnerable to the advertisement of financial incentives. Nevertheless, the environment in which we consume information shapes what we pay attention to. 

The consequences of this are neither immediate nor directly measurable. A single prediction market trend will not shape how an entire generation thinks; instead, the effects are more gradual. They show up in the habits we cultivate when we repeatedly treat human events as something to monetize. The issue is that the platforms that young people use to interact with the world will increasingly habituate them to a narrower, more cynical form of engagement. 

Ultimately, prediction markets are not the sole cause of this shift, and banning them will not resolve the deeper problems with how we consume information. Their appeal is rooted in the fact that people want to make sense of an uncertain future. But the danger of apps like Kalshi is that we might gradually begin to internalize these platforms’ worldview. We should resist a culture that makes concern contingent on having something to gain. Our responsibility is to understand what is at stake, not simply to predict what comes next.