Science

The Insect Apocalypse

Human activity is threatening the survival of insect populations to the point where entomologists have discussed the beginning of the insect apocalypse—a concerning decline in insect populations. Why are insects so important to us, and what can be done to save them?

Insects are a very prevalent part of our lives—fireflies illuminating summer nights, bees lazily buzzing around, earthworms squirming about on a rainy day. When was the last time you saw a whole field of fireflies? When was the last time you turned over a stone on a muddy hiking trail and saw a whole ecosystem of bugs residing under it? These human experiences are under threat due to a phenomenon known as the insect apocalypse. In the last half century, entomologists have determined that insect populations have declined by 75 percent, which has very drastic implications for the health and stability of Earth’s biosphere. 

The first catastrophic trends were observed in Germany. The Krefeld Society (a team of entomologists in Krefeld, Germany) has archived flying insects from nature reserves across Germany since 1905. Surprisingly, the number of insects trapped fell by 75 percent from 1989 to 2016. A similar trend of decline was revealed by a Puerto Rican study that showcased an insect population decline of 98 percent in a 35-year period. However, there are heated debates on whether the decline is a global pattern or has geographic limitations. In a study published in 2020, biologist Matthew D. Morgan and ecologist Bill Snyder analyzed insect populations in North America in an attempt to verify whether the trends found in European insect populations held true on a wider scale. After a thorough analysis of almost 40 years of data on insect populations in 28 sites across the U.S., ranging from deserts to forest habitats, the study illustrated that most insect populations had indistinguishable fluctuations in size. 

Morgan attempted to contextualize European trends by stating that Europe has cleared out most of its land for agricultural use and is dominated by urban landscapes, so logically insect populations are on a downward trend compared to earlier times. Even then, in spite of these inconsistencies in trends, both scientists and everyday people are starting to feel the absence of insects. This feeling of the absence of insects is known as the windshield effect. Danish naturalist Anders Pape Møller performed an experiment in which he drove down countryside roads and counted the number of bug splats on his windshield. He reported that his windshield remained clear of dead bugs, while that road trip a few decades ago would have required him to constantly clean his windshield.

It’s difficult to emphasize the significance of insects because they’ve developed a negative reputation as pests and carriers of deadly disease. Nevertheless, it is important to realize that insects account for a large portion of biodiversity on Earth—making up over 80 percent of Earth’s known species—and signs of decreasing biodiversity are typically an indicator of a decrease in overall ecosystem health. Because of their abundance, insects exist as the base of food webs all around the world. For example, insects such as caterpillars and grasshoppers are preyed upon by other insects such as wasps and beetles. In turn, these omnivorous insects such as wasps and beetles are a food source for birds, reptiles, amphibians, fish, bats, and even humans! 

The cost of pollination services delivered by insects on a global scale is estimated to be around $235 billion to $577 billion. The colorfulness of our planet would be drained without insects, as they are responsible for pollinating around 87 percent of known plant species. These vital pollinators include insects such as bumblebees, butterflies, beetles, and hoverflies. Try to imagine your life without cucumbers, watermelons, tomatoes, cherries, mangoes, and coffee. These are just a few examples of crops that depend on insect pollination and that people depend on for variety in their diets. In addition to pollinating plants, insects are directly involved in plant growth because they are vital for nutrient cycling in nature. They break down dead matter, releasing nutrients back into the soil, which are then used by plants for developmental processes. 

In regard to the insect apocalypse, flying insects seem to be taking the hardest hit, which unfortunately includes many pollinator species. The UK Butterfly Monitoring Scheme, an organization that keeps records of population trends of the UK’s butterflies, reported significant declines of up to 30 percent in populations of wider countryside butterfly species in numbers from 2014 compared to 1976. Wider countryside butterfly species are found in agricultural farmlands, and the statistic above indicates that these populations are not faring so well. 

The insect apocalypse is caused by various human activities, namely our contribution to climate change, habitat loss, and pesticide use. Climate change has pushed insects out of their natural habitats, as heightened temperatures and increased rainfall are unsuitable for insects’ adaptations. These shifts in climate have an impact on the feeding habits, migratory trends, and fertility of insect populations, along with other biological processes that alter their survival patterns. In addition, insects aren’t just being pushed out by unfavorable climate conditions, but also by our conversion of natural land into arable land: 11 percent of our land usage is for agricultural purposes. A common practice on arable lands is to use pesticides to protect crops from pests. However, these chemicals can be aggressive, devastating insect populations beyond the intended pest. Using pesticides creates a positive feedback loop: once the usage of pesticides is halted, the pests resurge in greater numbers because their natural predators have left. The pests may return with a greater resistance to previous pesticides due to genetic mutations, causing farmers to use more chemically potent pesticides. 

In an email interview, Mila Hsiung—one of the Research directors for the Stuyvesant Environmental Club—mentions, “The issue with the decline being in lesser-known [insect] populations is that people tend to not care until it affects them, and by the time it does, it will be irreparable.” She is right: the damage will be irreversible once everyone starts feeling an impact. There is still an opportunity to change how we choose to interact with and impact our environment. For one, we should restructure farming policies and turn toward a more organic approach, making more room for insects to thrive. Farmers can mass-produce crops while ensuring the preservation of insect populations by incorporating natural pollinators and biological pest management within their agroecosystems and growing wildflowers to attract said pollinators. The focus should be on preserving biodiversity while producing food in a sustainable manner without turning to chemical alternatives. This was achieved by the Anderson Almond farm in California—owners Glen and Leslie Anderson allowed wild pollinators to dominate the landscape and refrained from using synthetic pesticides. The impact of these practices is that the farm developed a sustainable agroecosystem that supports insect biodiversity, resulting in enhanced soil quality and long-term crop yields.

The childish fear of insects needs to be destigmatized. Destigmatization can be achieved through stronger efforts to spread environmental awareness: this starts by teaching younger generations about the importance of insects and learning to care about insects as much as any other animal. This can include reading entomological literature, paying attention to environmental policies concerning insect conservation, or simply choosing to not fear a bee that approaches you on your stroll.