The Dogs Become Beasts
The Peglegs, Stuyvesant’s boys’ soccer team reflect on a season that ended with a 3-0 playoff loss to Brooklyn Tech, and look ahead to replacing 12 departing seniors.

On the Peglegs, Stuyvesant boys’ soccer team, senior and striker Emmett Macrides goes by “the beast.” When a 3-0 Round of 16 loss to Brooklyn Technical High School ended the season on October 27, three words were all he had to say.
“Feed the beast.”
Next season, however, the beast won’t be around to feed. Macrides is one of 12 seniors who were part of the era that saw the Peglegs record three straight seasons of reaching at least the semifinals, including last year’s run to the team’s first PSAL final. Finding a replacement for them is one of the biggest challenges that the team currently faces.
This fall, the Peglegs recorded five wins, two losses, and three ties in the regular season, placing second in their division with 18 points. They started the season hot, scoring 20 goals in their first five games and picking up wins against Hunter College High School, Graphics Campus, and Beacon High School.
Then came the hardest test on the schedule: two games in one day against the division’s first-ranked Martin Luther King Jr. High School. MLK High School has stood in the Peglegs’ way before, knocking them out in the semifinals two years ago and handing them a division loss last season that nearly kept them out of the playoffs. The two-game day was needed because the teams’ season opener on September 11 had been suspended in the 71st minute with MLK High School leading 2-1 after a player was injured. MLK High School won the resumed game 4-2 and then took the second, 4-1. The back-to-back losses kicked off an offensive slowdown for the Peglegs. They scored only one goal in their last two regular-season games, draws of 0-0 and 1-1 against Washington Irving High School.
The Peglegs entered the playoffs as the 16th seed and faced the Academy of American Studies at Pier 40 on October 23. They won 2-1 thanks in large part to junior goalkeeper Rufus Schaffner who made 14 saves, more than a third of his season total of 40, and was named man of the match. This set up a rematch with Brooklyn Tech, the same team that had beaten them 2-0 in last year’s PSAL final.
The game gave the Peglegs a chance to avenge last year’s championship loss. Tech shut down most of Stuyvesant’s attacks, pressed hard, pushed forward quickly whenever it had the chance, and secured a 3-0 win. Tech has now ended Stuy’s season two years in a row by a combined score of 5-0. Whether the Peglegs can close that gap next fall depends on who can step up in place of a large senior class.
Macrides led the attack last season with eight goals and four assists, contributing to nearly half of the team’s 26 goals. Additionally, all three co-captains, defenders Zamir Karim and Sobel Gaudissard, along with midfielder Soichiro Sugawara, will be graduating, leaving gaps in the lineup beyond the attack. With that much experience leaving, the next team will rely heavily on this year’s juniors and sophomores.
“I hope the younger kids take this year’s mistakes and lessons and motivation to improve upon in the coming years,” Karim said. After scoring 20 goals in their first five games, the Peglegs scored just three in their last four following the MLK losses, and in the Round of 16, they were shut out completely. Sustaining their early season form for a full season will be a major deciding factor in how far the team goes next year.
“The team has a lot of returning talent and should hope to maintain the high expectation of success we have had in previous years. I believe in them to do great things. I wish them the best of luck and give them all of my love and support,” Karim added. “The talent has already started to flourish, and we’re seeing it in our juniors and sophomores.”
A prime example is junior winger Taiga Matsumoto who finished with eight goals and one assist. His scoring prowess has even earned him the nickname “mini beast.” Between the sticks, Schaffner will return next season after a 40-save season and a playoff man-of-the-match performance behind him.
“I know that Emmett, ‘The Beast,’ was one of the biggest factors in our success this year and I’ve got big shoes to fill, but I think I’ve got what it takes to be his successor and maybe even better [than him]. Knowing him, he’d definitely want me to surpass him and lead the team to greater success. We shared the title of the team’s top goalscorer this season with both of us having eight goals apiece, but the reason his name is displayed above mine on PSAL is because he had more assists, which I think reflects his character really well,” Matsumoto said. He is well aware of the role he has to play next season as the new beast. For that to happen, the beast needs to be fed.
What does that mean, though? This season, it meant getting the ball to Macrides, but next season, it will mean giving players like Matsumoto and Schaffner the opportunities and support to grow into leadership roles. Whether they can become the next beasts will decide how the Peglegs perform next season.
