Sydney Sweeney Has Mastered Cancel Culture
Analyzing numerous unsuccessful attempts to cancel Sydney Sweeney, and what they can teach us about cancel culture.

“Being canceled will ruin your life.” Certainly, for a powerless person who has no hope of combating a mob of angry justice-servers on X, that’s true. But with sufficient money, power, and strategy, the phrase “all press is good press” can still apply in the Internet era. If you don’t believe it, consider Sydney Sweeney. Sweeney, a popular American actress, has made a name for herself not just through her acting career but also by participating in typically inflammatory ad campaigns that are deemed bigoted by some way—and are also highly profitable.
Her latest endeavor was an ad campaign for the sports betting app Novig. In the first ad of the series, Sweeney, holding various pieces of sports equipment, repeats that Novig is “just sports,” and that there’s “no betting on wars or deaths, and no politics. Just sports.” (There are also no clothes). Immediately, the ad received backlash for its hypersexualization and objectification of Sweeney’s body to sell a completely unrelated product (mainly) to men. Female athletes criticized and shamed Sweeney for ignoring the struggles that women in sports, who are constantly objectified by their male counterparts, have to endure.
While there is always much debate over how gravely Sweeney has transgressed, it is always unequivocal that from a marketing standpoint, she has succeeded. Following the ad’s release, Novig stock increased by 300 percent (leading Sweeney to profit due to her stake in the company). Similarly, her 2025 ad campaign for American Eagle, “Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans,” was condemned for its resemblance to eugenics, but it still managed to increase American Eagle’s worth by $400 million. Season three of HBO’s Euphoria—the show in which Sweeney got her first major break—saw its finale produce 140 percent as much online conversation as its premiere, as well as increased viewership, even though the general consensus amongst fans was that it was simply not very good. This attention was due to the shock value of Sweeney’s character’s arc, which was criticized for being misogynistic and promoting the sexualization of children because of its explicit depiction of adult entertainment content creation.
We should realize by now that attempting to cancel Sydney Sweeney just doesn’t work. She doesn’t stop making provocative ads; in fact, Novig released a second “Just Sports” ad just a month after it released the first. She never posts half-hearted, publicist-reviewed apologies, promising to be a better person in the future. The closest she has come to doing so is saying that she regretted her silence upon the release of the American Eagle ad, which she stood by and said was misinterpreted. Instead of trying to cancel Sweeney the next time she shocks us (though, is it even shocking anymore?), we should try to understand what this phenomenon can teach us—not only about Sweeney, but about ourselves.
What is it about Sydney Sweeney that makes her completely un-cancelable? We can start by asking what it means for canceling someone to “work,” and what the point of cancel culture is, if there even is one. The goal of canceling someone, generally, is to tarnish the image of the accused enough so that they won’t commit their offense again in the future. But there is a reason that we call it “cancel culture” and not legal justice. Participants can mistake their own outrage for a responsibility and ability to bring justice, when in fact they possess neither. Social media users are not meant to carry out a trial, and they simply can’t because there is no such thing as due process when the defendant has no hope of their voice being heard. Often, cancel culture results in major hullabaloo without lasting change because it is half-hearted at its core. Participating in “canceling” someone is a low-risk, low-effort way to virtue signal, so some people engage not because of deep devotion to a cause, but because they want to check a box. We can thus define the successful canceling of someone in two ways: either the person is effectively socially “ended,” and due to this forced silence, unable to transgress again; or, more cynically, the people doing the canceling get the social validation they want. Both definitions have the appearance of practicality, but whether that really reflects their nature varies on a case-by-case basis. This illusion is exactly what Sweeney is manipulating.
Sydney Sweeney does provocative things because she wants us to believe that we can succeed in canceling and subsequently silencing her. But we can’t because she expects the storm, prepares for it, and prevents any real damage from ever occurring. She strategically teeters on the edge of offenses that unequivocally merit outrage, so as to provoke just enough resistance to attract press. There have always been enough people who don’t see her actions as truly wrong to balance out those who do. Who cares whether or not Sweeney wears pants while she promotes Novig? Did “Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans” really seek to recall eugenics, or was it just a stupidly misinterpretable pun? We may not find it respectable to sell soap with one’s bathwater in it, but Sweeney is free to do so. Her offenses are of a calculatedly ambiguous degree of reprehensibility, leaving her the space to return.
Brands keep hiring her because, though it may seem like it should be, doing so isn’t a suicide mission—in fact, it is the opposite. Backlash of the Sweeney flavor is profitable—so much so that companies partake in creating it. Public relations is the marketing of people. It is the job of Sweeney, her team, and the brands that hire her to generate profit through the manipulation of patterns, especially those involving the psychology of the consumer. While it may seem on the surface that Sweeney is selling her body, she is truly selling a persona that people can hate. Being canceled is the predictable, exploitable outcome of the actions she takes. While we can’t know for sure what Sweeney’s motivation is, it certainly seems like it’s money—and if so, it’s working.
The ease with which the public is manipulated merits self-reflection. We are so concerned about Sweeney’s negative impact that we rarely stop to consider the positive impact we actually create. Consider the Novig incident: it is true that the ad was shameless in its objectification of the female body. And yet, the condemnation of it did not actually accomplish anything concrete for the women the ad had supposedly harmed. The real harm Sweeney causes is that she makes us bicker about things that don’t have to matter, and in doing so, takes public focus off causes that do. She encourages us to dwell on how she chooses not to clothe herself, but we don’t have to be complacent. We should resist. The scope of public focus is limited, and perhaps a better use of our time and attention would be fighting to change the fact that UNESCO reported that 21 percent of female athletes report experiencing sexual abuse as children, or that the U.S. still does not guarantee paid maternity leave and is the only such country in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. Instead of temporarily keeping a hashtag trending, we must become devoted to a cause and fight for it.
Why might we be inclined to choose the former, even if the choice is subconscious? Because it is far easier. The reason that there are so many problems in the world isn’t that no one wants to solve them; it’s that it is monstrously difficult to do so. It feels great to tell yourself that you have created positive change, so of course people will repost something that appears to be fighting misogyny or racism, even if it won’t have a real impact. The outrage Sweeney arouses may stem from benevolence, but it doesn’t stay that way. It quickly becomes a performance to virtue signal an alliance with causes that the performers either don’t genuinely care about or are too lazy to truly fight for.
When the Instagram stories and hashtags fade, we are left with the same world we began in—one in which the cancellation of Sydney Sweeney is, has been, and will continue to be pointless. It is not only a performance but a transaction, in which participants get to feel like they have contributed to justice, while Sweeney gets money. As we rack up receipts, we strengthen the ice Sweeney walks on. Fame may be ephemeral, but infamy is not.
There is a way to stop this cycle, though it is relatively undramatic and carries no sense of moral heroism. We can simply allow Sydney Sweeney to fade into obscurity. Instead of perpetuating what we denounce, we can disregard what Sweeney wants us to scream about and scream for the people who need it. Silence is deadly.