Lanterns: Swing and a Miss
Why Lanterns is a drama, not a superhero show.
After the disaster of a movie that was Green Lantern (2011), Green Lantern fans needed a win. Whether Lanterns (2026) has revitalized the character is a point of controversy. Lanterns’s first season is an odd case of a show steering away from its roots—so much so that it leaves behind some of the fundamentals. The show follows Green Lantern Hal Jordan (Kyle Chandler) and his pupil John Stewart (Aaron Pierre) over several decades as they fight the last remaining Manhunter aliens in Rushville, Indiana. At its core, though, the show is a portrayal of a twisted mentor and mentee relationship. Lanterns manages to have a compelling central drama, yet it falls flat when it comes to some of the key components of a superhero show.
Lanterns excels in the amount of time it devotes to character development. Due to the show covering such a large timeframe, Hal is portrayed in the context of his entire life, beginning with his origins as a hotshot superhero in 1996. Most of the time is spent portraying Hal from 2016, who is a jaded, lonely, despised old man. The show’s large time span allows an expansive depiction of Hal as a dense character who the audience has an intimate connection with, and who, despite being a supernatural figure, feels as real as a character in a more grounded, realistic show.
John also has a well-crafted character arc. At the start of the show, he is cold and mysterious, yet the show dedicates an entire episode to explore his harsh upbringing. This episode functions as John’s origin, yet contains almost nothing supernatural. Considering it is the origin of a Green Lantern, John’s story could work as the origin of any type of character—superhero or not. For example, John’s motivation for being the Green Lantern, at least until the end of the show, is established in this episode as immense pressure from his parents.
Lanterns’ greatest success comes from the writing of both the two leads’ arcs. Both influenced each other significantly in 2016, and these influences are starkly visible in the present-day timeline. Despite starting the season jaded, Hal is inspired by John’s eagerness to help, and 10 years after their split, he is said to knock on people’s doors, asking how he can help. Conversely, John picks up on Hal’s defiance as, in the finale, he disobeys the Guardians (the authority over Green Lanterns).
To add to Lanterns’ strengths at character writing, the acting is quite good. Kyle Chandler pulls off Hal as multiple completely different versions of himself over the decades, from being harsh and near pitiful in 2016, to being more compassionate and earnest in his recurring hologram from 2006, and ultimately his more hardened yet humbled 2026 self, which is present in his last conversation with John. This older version of Hal may be unfamiliar to loyal Green Lantern comic readers, yet it works in the confines of the show. Along with Hal, Aaron Pierre portrays John well, portraying him as seemingly cold and mysterious, yet deeply morally guided.
Despite its strengths as a rather grounded character drama, Lanterns falls short when it comes to some of the most important aspects of a superhero show. Thoughtful character writing and good acting are not the distinguishing elements of the superhero genre. Instead, the emphasis is usually on action and a fast-paced, engaging plot. Lanterns doesn’t excel at any of these.
When it comes to action, Lanterns has almost nothing to show for itself. The Green Lantern ring is used sparingly throughout the show, and in most instances it merely projects a circular green shield. As far as actual fight scenes, the only significant instance comes in the fifth episode, which features gunfights, a fistfight brawl between Hal and John, and several explosions. Lanterns is disappointing in its action, to say the least. This result could be chalked up to a low budget, but the show had a budget of 10 to 20 million dollars per episode. For a show without any A-list stars, that figure seems like enough for a better quantity and quality of action. For comparison, The Boys also has a budget of around 10 to 20 million dollars per episode over its entire run, and it is covered with expensive CGI and fight scenes. It seems like the reason for Lanterns’ shortcomings in action is merely a director’s choice for a more grounded show, yet it comes at the cost of Lanterns not living up to the modern standard for superhero media.
The plot of Lanterns is serviceable, but lacking in many areas. At times, the show seems to want to be a mystery. The 2016 timeline plays out like an episode of Scooby-Doo, in which much of its runtime is devoted to discovering the identity of the show’s main villain, the last known Manhunter. Additionally, the present-day timeline seems to set up a whodunnit on the murder of Hal Jordan. The problem with these mysteries is that Lanterns does not commit enough. Instead of engaging the viewer with an intriguing setup, the show still decides to play out like a typical action show, where the plot is constantly moving, and viewers are supposed to simply watch along mindlessly. Few characters are introduced in the show, so finding the identity of the Manhunter is easy and only requires the process of elimination. The same issue does not apply to the whodunnit mystery in the present-day timeline, where instead of an intriguing mystery and a satisfying reveal, there is little setup, and the reveal is pure shock-bait out of left field. In fact, the finale undoes much of the grounded aspect established in the rest of the show by cramming in an illogical twist that undermines the story’s coherence, which betrays the audience’s perception of the events as a reflection of the real world. The writers’ strategy for resolving plotlines in the finale seems to be simply using the first idea that comes to an untrained writer’s mind if they were told that the goal is shock value.
Lastly, the area of the show that has seemed to garner the most controversy is its faithfulness to the comics. It’s worth noting that being faithful to the original does not make or break an adaptation. For example, James Gunn’s own Guardians of the Galaxy is highly unfaithful to the comics in many ways, yet it is a landmark film for the MCU and the superhero genre. Lanterns has some pretty faithful parts, with Hal Jordan, despite being older than most of his comic counterparts, portraying the familiar cockiness of comic Hal. John Stewart definitely carries over his core traits, like his integrity and no-nonsense attitude, but these are examples of the bare minimum of comic book accuracy. There seems to be a lot of rage online over certain ways that Lanterns strays from the comics. Some of the discourse is trivial, as the show cannot adapt every detail in the vast installments of the Green Lantern comics. The pressing problem that Lanterns has with faithfulness is that it isn’t focused on being a Green Lantern show. Some of the most recognizable parts of the Green Lantern identity are absent: the suit is never worn, they rarely go off-planet, they barely interact with aliens at all, and the constructs are never used as a plot point.
The conflicts between the protagonists and the villains don’t take priority over the conflicts between characters. The show’s narratives of eliminating alien threats are somewhat uninteresting, whereas the fighting between the two leads, and their ever-changing relationship, become the main appeal. This friction is engaging, but it is not unique to Green Lantern. This makes Lanterns more of a drama than a superhero show.
Lanterns may have been an enjoyable watch, but it did not live up to expectations. The creators clearly showcased their ability to make a decent show with good characters, but the Green Lantern aspect doesn’t come through strongly. The final result is a show that shies away from its own identity, holding itself back from being the celebration of Green Lantern that fans deserve.
