A Quantum Deal Washington Should Copy
New York’s new quantum lab backs small companies and gives money back to the public, and our country should follow its lead.
On the ground floor of 770 Broadway is a Wegmans, where you can buy a bag of avocados, a rotisserie chicken, and a pint of blueberries. A few floors up, starting in 2030, researchers will be building quantum chips: processors that harness the strange behavior of atoms to do things computers can’t, from modeling new medicines to sending top-secret messages that can’t be intercepted. The quantum technology industry is projected to generate more than $2.7 trillion in economic value by 2035, and our city will soon become a big player on the field.
The city’s new “QFab,” short for Quantum Fabrication Facility, was announced by Mayor Mamdani in collaboration with New York University (NYU) and the New York City Economic Development Corporation just a few weeks ago. It is the smartest economic decision the city has made in years. Our city’s quantum lab will educate a new generation of researchers, invest public money in small companies rather than international tech giants, and give cuts of the proceeds back to the city. Our national government should be taking notes.
Our city government is contributing $29.2 million in funding alongside NYU’s generous $255 million to build the lab and fund its technology. In exchange, the city will receive three seats on the QFab Advisory Board and 15 percent of NYU’s proceeds from any invention or discovery that turns a profit. If the research pays off as predicted, the city will benefit, and a portion of the money put in would come back to New Yorkers through city projects instead of staying entirely in private hands. It’s an easy win-win. Although no specific projects have been named, the mayor certainly has a large to-do list following the projected passing of all five midterm ballot proposals from the midterms. Many of the proposals create expedited review processes for city infrastructure, making it easier to build things like housing complexes, ramps, and sidewalk cafés. Ideally, the combination of faster-passing legislation and increased future funding from the quantum lab will make city projects move more quickly.
To see why this matters, it helps to understand what a quantum research facility actually is. Quantum chips can’t be built in a garage. The necessary materials are extremely sensitive to their environment, and research requires the use of expensive refrigerators, vacuum chambers, lasers, and microwave electronics. On its own, it’s almost impossible for a small company to get a foothold in the quantum research world, especially when federal funding is increasingly funneled to giant corporations and major labs. QFab will open its doors to companies that couldn't afford these innovations on their own.
The national precedent favors quantum research companies that are already powerful. The United States spends hundreds of millions of dollars on quantum research every year. President Trump has made it clear that winning the quantum research race is essential to preserving the American technological edge on the global stage. Last year, the Department of Energy renewed five national quantum research centers for $625 million. They’re currently run by federal labs in partnership with mega-corporations like IBM and Intel. When payday comes, those few companies get all of the rewards. Moreover, this spring, the Department of Commerce split $2 billion among nine quantum companies and took equity in each one. But half of this money is going directly to IBM, a company already worth hundreds of billions of dollars.
As part of its function, QFab will incubate 50 new startups and provide fabrication services for 50 existing companies. In total, that’s a hundred young businesses in a field that will internationally shape the next several decades. Some might fail, but that’s the point of hedging your bets. For the city, it’s worth it in the long run to invest in small businesses—you never know which of them could be the next IonQ or IBM. QFab will also reach people that are usually left out of highbrow research. The lab will serve over 35,000 New Yorkers in its first 10 years of operation, including more than 5,000 undergraduate and graduate students. NYC public schoolers will be able to attend summer bootcamps and internships, and CUNY students can take new, select classes at the lab. Two of the city’s three QFab board seats go to CUNY colleges, the Borough of Manhattan Community College and City Tech. Federal quantum funding almost exclusively flows to graduate students and professionals at elite institutions, but this model will include the students who will become the future workforce.
Aside from contributing hands-on experiences for New Yorkers, this lab will also directly share its proceeds with the city. Even a small share of a breakthrough could be worth a lot. Already, costs for quantum labs are high. Money is spent primarily on long-term R&D and paying highly specialized physicists and scientists. Most companies are focused purely on research, with little to no marketing staff. Our nation is betting that, in the future, quantum research will pay out in its ability to improve cryptography, intelligence, and secure communications. But today, profitability comes from quantum-adjacent hardware that is ready for the markets, like atomic clocks and navigation sensors. Such inventions are currently deployed in aerospace and defense science.
It’s easy to criticize the construction of a quantum research facility on similar premises to opposing data centers. Both seem like hulking, large, and intimidating facilities that extract small-town resources for private corporate profit. And in some ways, they are similar. Like data centers, quantum research labs place a strain on local energy and water infrastructure because they rely on complex cooling and processing systems. But in the most important ways, they are vastly different. QFab will occupy 23,000 square feet in a building that NYU already leases, not a sprawling campus on cheap, rural land. Also, data centers typically pipe their profits to out-of-town corporations and leave the surrounding area with higher utility bills; QFab gives New Yorkers jobs (the city projects an estimated 2,000 permanent ones), training, and a share of the revenue. Besides, quantum labs are inarguably the next step in the American tech sector. They will be built somewhere regardless. If these labs are going to exist, it’s better for the profits to go to the public instead of a corporation that already has more money than it knows what to do with.
What can our nation do? New York City already has a template laid out. We must create revenue-sharing terms for all federal research funding, so that when a publicly funded lab creates something profitable (which the nation is already betting on), a cut of the profit returns to the public. There should be lab access and grant funding for small, specialized startups, not just the same handful of megacorporations we see today. Moreover, we should partner with community colleges and public universities, both to expand funding and provide opportunities for the future scientists, engineers, and researchers who are paying for it. New York struck this deal in a city where space can cost $1,500 per square foot. With far deeper pockets, Washington can surely do the same.
It’s not surprising that New York City is finally building its own quantum ecosystem; this city doesn’t like to fall behind Chicago, the D.C.–Maryland corridor, or Silicon Valley, each of which hold their own in this field. The city calls this revenue-sharing model the “first of its kind,” which should embarrass the agencies that have handed out public research money without getting anything back for their taxpayers. For decades, taxpayers have funded scientific breakthroughs while corporations and universities keep the rewards for themselves. Quantum technology will shape everything from cybersecurity to medicine, and the question of who gets to profit is being decided right now. By the time our Quantum Fabrication Facility opens in 2030, the rest of the country should already be copying it.